Same person?

Sis

Sis

Rootles out resources!
I would like people's opinion as to whether these signatures are of the same person please.

The first one was when he was about 25 years old and the second, if it's him, when he was about 63 years old. Sorry but the first one is about as clear as I can get it.

jonas 25.JPG jonas 1.JPG
 
I would say 'yes'
The first 'o's (Jonas) and the 'd's. To me, they are the giveaway.
He is very wobbly for a 63 year old though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sis
My initial thought based on the surname is that they're not the same, but who knows what 38 years of wear and tear could do?

Is there any possibility of larger images, please? (xx years of wear and tear on the visual apparatus at this end) Or can we find them online anywhere?
 
Both marriages are on Ancestry. This first one is Jonas Goodwin to Mary Riley 28 March 1796 at St Mary, Lambeth.

25.JPG

This one is at the same church but it is Jonas Goodwin to Mary Woods 10 February 1834

63.JPG
 
I would say yes, definitely.

It's an older person, but the same hand. Probably like me, couldn't remember where he'd left his reading glasses.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sis
I tend to agree with Arthur in that the surname looks somewhat different but, 38 years down the line, who knows how infirm he may have been. What dates are we talking about, Sis?

Janet

Sorry cross posted, so we now have the dates. Still not completely sure though.
 
Adding to that, several health conditions can make handwriting an almost impossible chore, my own Mannie has photographic I.D. at the bank due to changing handwriting.
 
I hope you can understand what I am trying to say here :confused:
Marriage of Jonas to Mary 1796
Marriage of Jonas to Mary 1834........
1841 census: 41 H0107 737/23....Institution
Jonas Goodwin 70 born M/sex
Mary Goodwin 50 born M/sex
Elizabeth Goodwin 21 born M/sex
1851 Census: 42 HO107 1479/758...Household
Jonas Goodwin 81 born M/sex Printers Compositor
Mary Goodwin 61 born WARRINGTON SOMERSET
Elizabeth Goodwin granddaughter 29 born M/sex.
 
Archie's Mum said:
I hope you can understand what I am trying to say here :confused:
Marriage of Jonas to Mary 1796
Marriage of Jonas to Mary 1834........
1841 census: 41 H0107 737/23....Institution
Jonas Goodwin 70 born M/sex
Mary Goodwin 50 born M/sex
Elizabeth Goodwin 21 born M/sex
1851 Census: 42 HO107 1479/758...Household
Jonas Goodwin 81 born M/sex Printers Compositor
Mary Goodwin 61 born WARRINGTON SOMERSET
Elizabeth Goodwin granddaughter 29 born M/sex.
Click to expand...
Yes, I have those thank you AM. I'm pretty sure that's him. He did a Printer's apprenticeship and I've got him in Bloomberg Street in the Westminster Rate Books from 1832 to '1857'. The only thing is that I can only find a death for a Jonas Goodwin, age 85, in Westminster district in '1856'. The age and area fit so I've just ordered it. Lets hope just maybe it will throw some sort of light on it all, who knows!
 
Sis said:
The only thing is that I can only find a death for a Jonas Goodwin, age 85, in Westminster district in '1856'. The age and area fit so I've just ordered it.
Click to expand...
Just received the Death PDF (within 5 working days!). It's the right Jonas Goodwin as the address is the same as in the Westminster Rate books and the age is right. It has confirmed also that at least the second signature in post #1 (marriage to Mary Woods) is my Jonas as the informant is a Frederick Woods, (https://genealogy-specialists.com/threads/frederick-goodwin-born-c-1825.8618/). For some reason known only to who know's who, I didn't look for Frederick under the surname Woods. Anyway that's another story!:D
 
His Cause of Death was.... Decay of Nature. Don't you just love the way they spoke!;)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top